Fall Dessert Recipes: Stained Glass Cookies

Scroll down to read the tutorial for these easy fall stained glass cookies

These fall stained glass cookies were really just an experiment. I had autumn leaf and flower cookie cutters and some beautiful glittery orange icing, so I wanted to see what would happen. I thought I was buying red-colored, cherry-flavored hard candy to make the stained glass windows. I was only half-right. They're cherry-flavored (and really tasty) but they were a bland yellow color. I had already opened the cookie dough package when I realized that, so I thought I'd give it a go anyway.

These cookies actually came out with a slight East Indian look, due to the colors and dots I used to decorate them. And there's nothing wrong with that. I just think most people would prefer a more colorful look. But the bottom line is that you can use whatever colors you want. I went the more natural/organic route with my cookies, but if you don't care about that, Jolly Rancher has some great hard candy in different flavors and colors. I must have eaten twice my weight in Jolly Ranchers during the course of my childhood, so I'm a big fan of their sweet and sour goodness.

Here's how I made the stained glass cookies:

Being somewhat exhausted from creating all the Christmas printables (cupcake toppers, gift bags and a paper wreath) for this blog, I took the easy way out and used packaged cookie dough. I also used organic hard candies, a nice Wilton leaf cookie cutter and a cheap flower cookie cutter I got in a set at the dollar store. Update 2018: Wilton now also a set of seven fall cookie cutters that could be really fun to use too.

Additionally, I used orange glitter piping gel from Charm City Cakes (featured on The Food Network's The Ace of Cakes).

You can get the general idea from these components and then adjust them according to your taste.


After waiting for the dough to warm up a bit, I rolled it out and cut it with the cutters.

I then cut out some holes with a sharp knife.

After putting the hard candies in a plastic bag and whacking the heck out of them with a hammer (in retrospect, I've decided that a food processor would have been a better choice for this task, presuming it could have handled the hardness of the candy), I  filled the holes I cut in the cookies with the broken pieces.

I also added non-pariels along with the broken hard candy in some of the cookies, to enhance the color and texture.

I used the orange icing to add dots and outlines to the cookies. I think these would benefit from having a coating of royal icing first, and maybe also having some other icing colors. But all in all, I think they came out pretty cute. Oh, and they tasted good too.

Happy Thanksgiving and happy baking!

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.  Amazon affiliate links are used in this post and in the sidebar, which means I will be paid a small commission if anything is purchased through them. This doesn't increase the amount you pay if you buy anything.


Post a Comment

I welcome your comments!